Events Logo

We make all of our Toma Brand Cheeses with milk from Brown Swiss cows that are raised naturally and hormone free on Lester Tyler's family farm, Sunny Acres Swiss
Cheeses aging in one of our three caves at carefully controlled temperature and humidity
Cheeses Photo
Assortment Photo

Toma con Brio 
Hot Sampler
Hot Sampler 2 Photo

This is our own version of the classic, bloomy rind cheese of France.  We make it extra thick so the texture ranges from molten at the rind to dense and rich in the center.  It is available with advance order in five pound wheels.


Toma Celena
Toma Celina

Toma Celena is a nutty and rich Italian table cheese that is our own creation. Its flavor is complex, hinting of toasted grains, apples and caramelized milk.  It is named after the first person to sample it, love it, and buy the first wheel. It is available in wheels of five, 30 and 50 pounds.


Jersey Girl Colby
Jersey Girl

This raw milk Colby made with milk from Autumn Valley Farm in Worcester, NY is very flavorful and creamy.  Autumn Valley Farm is entirely grass fed so the earthiness of the cow's milk is reflected in the deep yellow hue and rich hearty flavor of the cheese.  The cheese is currently available in 10 pound wheels.  Since the flavor of the cheese is so dependent on the availability of grass in the fields, the cheese is made in the spring and summer months so it is not always available all year long.



Jewelry Cheese Photo
Breakfast Basket Photo

Happy Cheese Makers (Sharon and Bob) at Work

Cheese Makers

Green Line

Contact Cooperstown Cheese Company

107 Oxbow Rd. at Rt. 28  Milford, NY 13807   Tel. 978.257.4635